Choosing between holeless vs. in-ground elevator jacks comes down to how far the car travels and what is under your pit.
Holeless jacks mount beside the car inside the hoistway, so nothing goes in the ground and corrosion stops being a concern.
In-ground jacks sit in a drilled hole below the pit and handle more floors.
For most low-rise Miami buildings, replacing a failed cylinder with a holeless jack is the better answer when the shaft allows it.
How The Two Designs Differ
An in-ground jack is a single cylinder in a drilled hole under the pit. The plunger connects to the bottom of the car and pushes it straight up.
One cylinder, one hole, travel limited mainly by how deep the hole is.
A holeless jack uses one or two cylinders mounted vertically in the hoistway, next to the car rather than under it.
On a telescoping or roped design, the stroke gets multiplied so the car travels farther than the cylinder is long.
Nothing is buried in a holeless setup. That single fact drives most decisions in South Florida.
Why Buried Cylinders Are A Harder Sell Here
Salt and a high water table are rough on steel in the ground. Cylinders installed decades ago were often sleeved in PVC and little else, and when that sleeve cracks, groundwater reaches the shell.
The failure is quiet. Oil leaves the system underground, so the pit stays dry while the reservoir drops.
By the time anyone notices, the fluid is in the soil, and you have a repair plus a possible environmental obligation.
This pattern shows up constantly in older Miami buildings with original hydraulic equipment.
A holeless jack removes that whole category of problem. The cylinders are exposed, so a tech can spot a weeping seal on a routine visit.
When In-Ground Is Still The Right Call
Travel. That is the main one.
Holeless designs top out at a practical travel limit, and in-ground units go higher. If your car serves more floors than a holeless jack can reach, the conversation ends there.
No single industry number exists because it depends on the jack design. Direct acting holeless units handle the shortest rises, often just a couple of stops.
Telescoping dual jack systems go further, and Schindler publishes 50 feet as the maximum standard travel for its 330A holeless line, with anything beyond that sent to engineering.
Roped holeless designs multiply stroke and reach even further.
Watch the hidden cost buried in those figures. On that same published table, travel past roughly 36 feet starts adding pit depth or overhead at about 4 inches for every additional foot of rise.
A taller holeless job quietly turns into a pit excavation or an overhead problem, which is the exact constraint a retrofit was supposed to dodge.
Confirm the number for your specific jack and roping configuration against the manufacturer’s current spec sheet, measured the way ASME A17.1 defines travel.
Two other cases keep in-ground in play:
- The hoistway is too narrow or has too little overhead to carry cylinders beside the car.
- A usable hole and a sound sleeve already exist, and the building is dry, so a new cylinder can go into a known good condition.
Loading matters too. Heavy-duty service cars and freight applications sometimes exceed what a holeless arrangement handles cleanly.
What A Holeless Conversion Needs From Your Hoistway
Before anyone quotes this, somebody has to measure. A holeless retrofit asks for space the original design never allocated.
The checks:
- Hoistway width and depth for cylinder placement on one or both sides of the car.
- Overhead clearance, because the cylinders and sheaves need room at the top of the stroke.
- Pit depth, since even holeless units need buffer and equipment space.
- Rail capacity, as the loading path changes from under the car to beside it.
- Door and sill geometry at every landing, which is where surprises hide.
Get the survey done by someone who will stand in the pit, not from drawings.
We have measured shafts where the drawings and reality disagreed by several inches, which is the difference between a clean conversion and a change order.
If the shaft itself is the constraint, it helps to understand what the hoistway has to accommodate.
Comparing Cost Honestly
Neither option is cheap, and the headline price isn’t a useful comparison.
In-ground replacement includes drilling or reusing the hole, the cylinder, pit restoration, waterproofing, and soil work if oil was lost.
Holeless conversion skips the drilling and the soil exposure but adds hoistway modification, often new rails or brackets, and sometimes controller and new pump unit work to match.
Over fifteen years, the in-ground option carries a risk the holeless option does not: another buried cylinder in the same wet ground.
If your unit is old enough that the cylinder is failing, the controller, valve, and fixtures are usually near the end too.
That is when a modernization project beats a string of repairs, and the framework for deciding is the same one in repair or replace.
The Limits Of This Comparison
This only applies to hydraulic elevators. If your building has traction equipment, neither jack type is relevant.
It also assumes you are replacing a failed or failing cylinder.
For new construction, the calculus includes machine room location, energy use, and whether a machine-room-less traction unit beats hydraulic altogether. That is a different analysis.
Measure The Shaft Before You Pick A Jack
Have your contractor survey the hoistway and pit, in person, and hand you the dimensions in writing.
Those numbers decide whether holeless is even available to you, and they turn a two-option debate into a one-option answer most of the time.
If you are already losing oil underground, treat the survey as urgent rather than planning work.
Our crews handle South Miami elevator repair and can measure the shaft while the unit is still running.